Past Debates
TUESDAY MAY 13, 2008
PAST DEBATE
WE SHOULD LEGALIZE THE MARKET FOR HUMAN ORGANS
FOR THE MOTION
MODERATOR
AGAINST THE MOTION
Lloyd R. Cohen
Lloyd R. Cohen
Lloyd R. Cohen
FOR THE MOTION
Lloyd R. Cohen
professor of law at George Mason University, has published scholarship on a variety of applications of economics to law, including a market in transplant organs, marriage and divorce, wrongful death, tender offers, and free riders and holdouts. Before joining the faculty of George Mason in 1993, he taught law at Chicago-Kent College of Law and was a John M. Olin Research Fellow at the University of Chicago. Cohen has served as a special counsel to the U.S. International Trade Commission and as a law clerk to Judge Gerald B. Tjoflat of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit. Before attending law school, he was an economics professor.
Amy L. Friedman
Amy L. Friedman
Amy L. Friedman
FOR THE MOTION
Amy L. Friedman
M.D., is the director of transplantation and professor of surgery at SUNY Upstate Medical University. Trained at Princeton, SUNY Downstate, and the University of Pennsylvania, she previously served on the faculties of Penn and Yale University. On numerous society boards, she is a member of the American Society of Transplant Surgeons, and is secretary of the American Association of Kidney Patients. Her immediate family includes two transplant recipients and one live donor.
Sally Satel
Sally Satel
Sally Satel
FOR THE MOTION
Sally Satel
M.D., is a resident scholar at AEI and a psychiatrist at the Oasis Clinic in Washington, D.C. Satel was an assistant professor of psychiatry at Yale University from 1988 to 1993. She has written widely in academic journals on topics in psychiatry and is the author of PC, M.D.: How Political Correctness Is Corrupting Medicine (2001), and is co-author of One Nation under Therapy (2005). Now, she is editing a book on donor compensation (AEI Press), an interest dating to 2006 when she received a kidney from a friend.
Ira Flatow
Ira Flatow
Ira Flatow
MODERATOR
Ira Flatow
is a veteran NPR® science correspondent and an award-winning TV journalist. He is the host of NPR®’s Talk Of The Nation: Science Friday®. He anchors the show each Friday, bringing radio and internet listeners world wide a lively, informative discussion on science, technology, health, space and the environment. His most recent book is Present at the Future: From Evolution to Nanotechnology, Candid and Controversial Conversations On Science and Nature (HarperCollins).
James F. Childress
James F. Childress
James F. Childress
AGAINST THE MOTION
James F. Childress
is the Hollingsworth Professor of Ethics at the University of Virginia, where he directs the Institute for Practical Ethics and Public Life. He is the author of numerous articles and several books in bioethics, including, with Tom L. Beauchamp, Principles of Biomedical Ethics (6th edition forthcoming in 2008). Childress was vice chair of the national Task Force on Organ Transplantation and has also served on the Board of Directors of the United Network for Organ Sharing (UNOS). He chaired the Institute of Medicine Committee that produced the report, "Organ Donation: Opportunities for Action" (2006).
Francis L. Delmonico
Francis L. Delmonico
Francis L. Delmonico
AGAINST THE MOTION
Francis L. Delmonico
M.D., is professor of surgery at Harvard Medical School and director of medical affairs of The Transplantation Society (TTS). He works closely with the World Health Organization, where he has been appointed as an advisor on organ transplantation. In addition, he is the medical director of the New England Organ Bank (NEOB) and director of educational activities for the Transplantation Unit at Massachusetts General Hospital.
David Rothman
David Rothman
David Rothman
AGAINST THE MOTION
David Rothman
Bernard Schoenberg Professor of Social Medicine and director of the Center on Medicine as a Profession at Columbia. Trained as a social historian, he has written widely on medicine. His subjects include the history of caretaker institutions, the implications of the rise of bioethics and law for medicine, and medical professionalism with a focus on conflict of interest. His recent book, Trust is Not Enough (2006) addresses among other issues, the ethics of research in third-world countries and how markets in organs for transplantation have become a worldwide phenomena.
poll-placeholder
SHARE THIS DEBATE WITH OTHERS
Bookmark and Share
PRE-DEBATE VOTE:

FOR: 44% AGAINST: 27% UNDECIDED: 29%

POST-DEBATE VOTE:

FOR: 60% AGAINST: 31% UNDECIDED: 9%

MODERATOR
Ira Flatow is a veteran NPR® science correspondent and an award-winning TV journalist. He is the host of NPR®’s Talk Of The Nation: Science Friday®. He anchors the show each Friday, bringing radio and internet listeners world wide a lively, informative discussion on science, technology, health, space and the environment. His most recent book is Present at the Future: From Evolution to Nanotechnology, Candid and Controversial Conversations On Science and Nature (HarperCollins).

FOR THE MOTION

Lloyd R. Cohen, professor of law at George Mason University, has published scholarship on a variety of applications of economics to law, including a market in transplant organs, marriage and divorce, wrongful death, tender offers, and free riders and holdouts. Before joining the faculty of George Mason in 1993, he taught law at Chicago-Kent College of Law and was a John M. Olin Research Fellow at the University of Chicago. Cohen has served as a special counsel to the U.S. International Trade Commission and as a law clerk to Judge Gerald B. Tjoflat of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit. Before attending law school, he was an economics professor.

Amy L. Friedman, M.D., is the director of transplantation and professor of surgery at SUNY Upstate Medical University. Trained at Princeton, SUNY Downstate, and the University of Pennsylvania, she previously served on the faculties of Penn and Yale University. On numerous society boards, she is a member of the American Society of Transplant Surgeons, and is secretary of the American Association of Kidney Patients. Her immediate family includes two transplant recipients and one live donor.

Sally Satel, M.D., is a resident scholar at AEI and a psychiatrist at the Oasis Clinic in Washington, D.C. Satel was an assistant professor of psychiatry at Yale University from 1988 to 1993. She has written widely in academic journals on topics in psychiatry and is the author of PC, M.D.: How Political Correctness Is Corrupting Medicine (2001), and is co-author of One Nation under Therapy (2005). Now, she is editing a book on donor compensation (AEI Press), an interest dating to 2006 when she received a kidney from a friend.

AGAINST THE MOTION

James F. Childress is the Hollingsworth Professor of Ethics at the University of Virginia, where he directs the Institute for Practical Ethics and Public Life. He is the author of numerous articles and several books in bioethics, including, with Tom L. Beauchamp, Principles of Biomedical Ethics (6th edition forthcoming in 2008). Childress was vice chair of the national Task Force on Organ Transplantation and has also served on the Board of Directors of the United Network for Organ Sharing (UNOS). He chaired the Institute of Medicine Committee that produced the report, “Organ Donation: Opportunities for Action” (2006).

Francis L. Delmonico, M.D., is professor of surgery at Harvard Medical School and director of medical affairs of The Transplantation Society (TTS). He works closely with the World Health Organization, where he has been appointed as an advisor on organ transplantation. In addition, he is the medical director of the New England Organ Bank (NEOB) and director of educational activities for the Transplantation Unit at Massachusetts General Hospital.

David Rothman, Bernard Schoenberg Professor of Social Medicine and director of the Center on Medicine as a Profession at Columbia. Trained as a social historian, he has written widely on medicine. His subjects include the history of caretaker institutions, the implications of the rise of bioethics and law for medicine, and medical professionalism with a focus on conflict of interest. His recent book, Trust is Not Enough (2006) addresses among other issues, the ethics of research in third-world countries and how markets in organs for transplantation have become a worldwide phenomena

*All Panelists are subject to change without notice

We have moved to a new venue: NYU SKIRBALL CENTER (566 LaGuardia Place)      Reception 5:45 - 6:30PM      Debate 6:45 - 8:30PM      Tickets $45
The pre-debate reception offers an opportunity to meet other New Yorkers and mingle with the evening's panelists. Enjoy complimentary wine and soft drinks in the Skirball Center lobby from 5:45 - 6:30PM and gain priority access to the auditorium. Doors open at 6:30PM for debate-only ticket holders.

Video

Audio

Audio Edited
Audio Unedited