Intelligence Squared US

TUESDAY, OCTOBER 27, 2009

GOOD RIDDANCE TO MAINSTREAM MEDIA

About This Debate

Mainstream media is dying. The network evening news audience is in steady decline; the big three magazine publishers, Time Inc., Condé Nast and Hearst have all closed or consolidated titles; and the newspaper industry has been especially ravaged, with dailies folding across the country. Increasingly people get their news from the internet and from cable channels. Advertisers are moving on to Google and other non-traditional sources. Do these developments leave us better off?

The democratization of news, in an unfiltered internet to which all bloggers and news aggregators have equal access, is a good thing. It encourages a diversity of voices, competing to provide information and analysis. Others argue that the public loses when traditional journalistic standards are no longer upheld, and where resources to investigate and report critical stories are no longer available. Can mainstream media re-invent itself to thrive in a digital age? Does it matter?

The Panel

For The Motion

  • John Hockenberry
    John Hockenberry
    FOR THE MOTION
    John Hockenberry
    is co-host of The Takeaway, a national morning news program co-produced by WNYC Radio and Public Radio International. During his time at ABC and NBC, he earned four Emmy Awards, three Peabody Awards, an Edward R. Murrow Award, and a Casey Medal.
  • Jim VandeHei
    Jim VandeHei
    FOR THE MOTION
    Jim VandeHei
    is executive editor of Politico. In the fall of 2006, VandeHei, along with co-founder John Harris, left the Washington Post to create Politico, now one of the nation’s most influential websites and newspapers.
  • Michael Wolff
    Michael Wolff
    FOR THE MOTION
    Michael Wolff
    is a columnist for Vanity Fair and the founder of news aggregator newser.com. His latest book is The Man Who Owns the News (2008), a biography of Rupert Murdoch.

Against The Motion

  • Katrina vanden Heuvel
    Katrina vanden Heuvel
    AGAINST THE MOTION
    Katrina vanden Heuvel
    is editor and publisher of the Nation. She is the editor of several books including, Meltdown: How Greed and Corruption Shattered Our Financial System and How We Can Recover (2009) and co-editor of Taking Back America--And Taking Down The Radical Right (2004).
  • David Carr
    David Carr
    AGAINST THE MOTION
    David Carr
    writes a column for the Monday Business section of the New York Times that focuses on media issues including print, digital, film, radio and television.
  • Phil Bronstein
    Phil Bronstein
    AGAINST THE MOTION
    Phil Bronstein
    began his journalism career in his teens as a film reviewer. He joined the San Francisco Examiner as a reporter in 1980, and beginning in 1983, spent 10 years as a war correspondent where he was a 1986 Pulitzer Prize finalist for his work in the Philippines.

Moderator

John Donvan is an author and correspondent for ABC News. He has served as ABC’s White House Correspondent, along with postings in Moscow, London, Jerusalem and Amman. He is currently writing a book on the history of autism to be published by Crown in 2013.

Poll Results

Pre-Debate Poll Results
25% For | 50% Against | 25%

Post Debate Poll Results
24% For | 68% Against | 8%

Debate Media

Video

Audio

Listen to the edited radio
broadcast of this debate
Listen to the full unedited
audio from this debate