Intelligence Squared US

MONDAY, NOVEMBER 22, 2010

U.S. AIRPORTS SHOULD USE RACIAL AND RELIGIOUS PROFILING

MONDAY, NOVEMBER 22, 2010

Reception:5:45 - 6:30PM

Debate:6:45 - 8:30 PM

NYU Skirball Center
566 LaGuardia Place
at Washington Square South
New York, NY 10012

Tickets:$40

About This Debate

On Christmas Day, 2009, twenty-three-year-old Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab attempted to blow up Northwest Airlines Flight 253 using explosives hidden in his underwear. A string of missed opportunities and errors by government security agencies culminated in what President Obama would declare a “systemic failure.” Is scanning everyone with expensive, high-tech equipment the best use of limited resources? Or should we use the information that we have—the knowledge that, while all Muslims are not terrorists, most terrorists are Muslim.

The Panel

For The Motion

  • Robert Baer
    Robert Baer
    FOR THE MOTION
    Robert Baer
    was a CIA case officer in the Directorate of Operations from 1976 to 1997, where he served in Middle Eastern countries, including Iraq and Lebanon. He is the author of two New York Times bestsellers: Sleeping with the Devil, about the Saudi royal family and its relationship with the United States; and See No Evil.
  • Deroy Murdock
    Deroy Murdock
    FOR THE MOTION
    Deroy Murdock
    is a syndicated columnist with the Scripps Howard News Service and media fellow with the Hoover Institution on War, Revolution and Peace at Stanford University. His column, “This Opinion Just In…” reaches approximately 400 newspapers across America each week.
  • Asra Q. Nomani
    Asra Q. Nomani
    FOR THE MOTION
    Asra Q. Nomani
    a former reporter for the Wall Street Journal for 15 years, is the author of Standing Alone: An American Woman's Struggle for the Soul of Islam. She is co-director of the Pearl Project, an investigation into the murder of Wall Street Journal reporter Daniel Pearl. Her activism for women's rights at her mosque in W.V. is the subject of a PBS documentary, The Mosque in Morgantown. She recently published a monograph, Milestones for a Spiritual Jihad: Toward an Islam of Grace.

Against The Motion

  • Hassan Abbas
    Hassan Abbas
    AGAINST THE MOTION
    Hassan Abbas
    is Quaid-i-Azam Professor at SIPA, Columbia University. He is also a senior advisor at the Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs at the Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University and BErnard Schwartz Fellow at Asia Society in New York. Abbas has also been a visiting fellow at the Islamic Legal Studies Program at Harvard Law School and a visiting scholar at the Harvard Law School's Program on Negotiation. Prior to his academic career, Abbas served as a government official in the administrations of Prime Minister Benazir Bhutto and President Pervez Musharraf. While in the Police Service of Pakistan in the late 1990s, he served in the North-West Frontier Province (now Khyber Pukhtunkhwa).
  • Debra Burlingame
    Debra Burlingame
    AGAINST THE MOTION
    Debra Burlingame
    is the sister of Charles F. “Chic” Burlingame, III, pilot of American Airlines flight 77, which crashed into the Pentagon on September 11, 2001. She is the co-founder of 9/11 Families for a Safe and Strong America and a director of the National September 11 Memorial and Museum Foundation at the World Trade Center.
  • Michael Chertoff
    Michael Chertoff
    AGAINST THE MOTION
    Michael Chertoff
    served as secretary of the U.S. Department of Homeland Security from 2005 to 2009. Before heading up the Department of Homeland Security, he served as a federal judge on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit, and as a federal prosecutor for more than a decade.

Moderator

John Donvan is a correspondent for ABC News Nightline. He has served as ABC White House Correspondent, along with postings in Moscow, London, Jerusalem and Amman.

Point/Counterpoint

For

  • It makes sense to add this extra layer of screening to everything else the TSA does.
  • Profiling is based on the probability of risk—the fact that there are outliers does not mean we shouldn’t screen for race or religion.
  • Full-body scanners are unreliable, at best.

Against

  • Focusing on Muslims means making false exclusion —profiling would not have caught the half Jamaican shoe bomber Richard Reid or blonde-haired, blue-eyed Jihad Jane—that make us less safe, not more.
  • We need to engage in behavioral profiling—buying a one-way ticket, boarding with no luggage, and avoidance of eye-contact are all examples of suspicious behavior.
  • Racial and religious profiling is unconstitutional, institutionalized racism.