More praise for IQ2 US
“It's a real public service to have debates that bring top-tier participants together and add the sizzle of prize fight competition to a discussion of issues of first-order importance.”
- The Atlantic
Embrace the Common Core
From the Panel
For: CARMEL MARTIN
- Common Core Implementation Best Practices
Carmel Martin, Center for American Progress, February 28, 2014The Center for American Progress believes that this is the biggest education reform in decades. If done well, it will lead to dramatic improvements in educational opportunities.
- A Guide to Common Core State Standards
Center for American Progress, December 4, 2013Fact sheets on states implementing the Common Core.
- The Common Core Is an Opportunity for Education Equity
Center for American Progress, May 19, 2014The Common Core helps address inequity in education by ensuring all students are taught to the same high standards and held to the same rigorous expectations.
- Why More States Are Backing off Common Core
Carmel Martin and Frederick Hess, News Hour, July 3, 2014Jeffrey Brown talks to Rick Hess of the American Enterprise Institute and Carmel Martin of the Center for American Progress about the backlash behind the standards, and the debate that lies ahead.
- Roadmap for a Successful Transition to the Common Core in States and Districts
Carmel Martin, Max Marchitello, and Melissa Lazarín, Center for American Progress, June 25, 2014Although no state has implemented the standards perfectly, there are many examples of best practices to help states course correct where needed without compromising the integrity of the Common Core or the benefits it will have for students. Building on these best practices, CAP recommends that states and districts focus their efforts on nine critical steps required to effectively translate standards into high-quality instruction.
- Common Core State Standards Assessments
Morgan S. Polikoff, Center for American Progress, April 17, 2014Despite the keenness for the CCSS and forthcoming tests, there are a number of likely challenges to the new standards and assessment systems. The purpose of this report is to outline some of these key challenges and offer suggestions for state and federal policymakers to mitigate them.
For: MICHAEL PETRILLI
- Common Core Standards Initiative
Michael Petrilli, Common Core Watch, September 3, 2014In NRO today, Rick Hess explores “five half-truths” that he says supporters of the Common Core like to propagate. These spurred five questions of my own.
- Restarting the Common Core Debate
Michael J. Petrilli and Neal P. McCluskey, September 1, 2014We — one Core advocate, one opponent — want to assist by laying out the facts on which we think everyone should agree.
- Common Core Standards Initiative
Michael Petrilli, C-SPAN, April 24, 2014Petrilli explains the role of the Common Core Standards in overall U.S. education policy and the ongoing debate over the adoption of the standards in states.
- Common Core: The Great Debate
Neal McCluskey, Emmet McGroarty, Chester Finn, and Michael Petrilli, Cato Institute, October 3, 2013A debate on the Common Core.
- 6 Reasons Why Conservatives Should Back Common Core
Chester Finn Jr. and Michael Petrilli, Detroit Free Press, September 22, 2013Rather than fight Common Core, those on the right should declare victory.
- Lies, Damned Lies, and the Common Core
Michael Petrilli, Education Next, February 10, 2014If you want to understand why supporters of the Common Core are frustrated—OK, exasperated—by some of our opponents’ seemingly unlimited willingness to engage in dishonest debate, consider this latest episode.
- The Splintering School Reform Movement
Michael Petrilli, Education Next, July 15, 2014One of the great misconceptions in education is that the reform movement is monolithic.
- Common Core: Too Little Change, Not Too Much
Michael Petrilli, Education Next, May 6, 2014Common Core will not lead to a national curriculum. Local control is alive and well, as it should be. But that’s not to say anything goes in the Common Core era or that changes to teaching and learning aren’t needed.
- A Point-by-Point Rebuttal of Today’s Anti-Common Core Op-Ed in the Weekly Standard
Michael Petrilli, Flypaper, May 30, 2013Debunking half-truths and misinformation.
- Find Out Why This Prominent Conservative Supports the Common Core
Evan Belanger, AL.com, December 17, 2013So what's conservative about the Common Core? Petrilli says it’s all about accountability.
Against: CAROL BURRIS
- I Was Naïve About Common Core
Carol Burris, Washington Post, March 4, 2013When I first read about the Common Core State Standards, I cheered.
- What New Common Core Test Scores Show
Carol Burris, Washington Post, August 27, 2014The original embrace of the Race to the Top reforms was understandable and forgivable. The continuation of the reforms — despite the mounting evidence of failure — is not.
- How College Remediation Rates Are Distorted—and Why
Carol Burris, Washington Post, July 7, 2014No matter how serious a problem it may be, it is wrong to inflate remediation numbers and then use them to justify everything from charter schools to the Common Core.
- A Disturbing Look at Common Core Tests in New York
Carol Burris and John Murphy, Washington Post, June 28, 2014Is the Common Core and its tests the path to college readiness? We think not.
- The Scary Way Common Core Test ‘Cut Scores’ Are Selected
Carol Burris, Washington Post, April 30, 2014There is no objective science by which we can predict future college readiness using grades 3-8 test scores. You can, at best make assumptions, based on correlations, with score thresholds that are capricious.
- How Politicians Ignore Parents on School Reform
Carol Burris, Washington Post, April 1, 2014It has become clear that in New York State, the ‘canary in the coal mine’ of the Common Core reforms, parents are sending a clear message by opting out.
- Are American Students Grossly Unprepared for College?
Carol Burris, Washington Post, March 17, 2014Misinformation is part of a continuing strategy to paint a picture of American public schools as failures in order to sell the public the Common Core, charter schools and the corporate reform agenda.
- ‘Storm of Reform’—Principal Details Damage Done
Carol Burris, Washington Post, March 11, 2013I have concluded that the standards, as they are being implemented, are potentially harmful to students.
- The Myth of Common Core Equity
Carol Burris, Washington Post, March 10, 2014If a goal of public education is to expand the life chances of all students, why are we pursuing punitive policies and practices that push the opportunities of our most vulnerable students even further behind?
- Why Test-Based School Reform Isn’t Working—By the Numbers
Carol Burris, Washington Post, February 24, 2014A study by the National Association of College Admission Counseling found that student college success was better predicted by high school grades than by test scores.
Against: FREDERICK HESS
- Common Core's Five Big Half-Truths
Frederick Hess, National Review, September 3, 2014A handy cheat sheet for putting the Common Core talking points in context.
- The Race to Nowhere
Frederick Hess, The Hill, August 5, 2014A monument to paper promises and bureaucratic ineptitude, Race to the Top was more a cautionary tale than a model to be emulated.
- What Ails the Common Core
Frederick Hess, National Review, June 13, 2014Most of the problems were caused by proponents’ rejecting the principles of federalism.
- Common Core Critics Can’t Just Say No
Frederick Hess and Michael McShane, National Review, April 14, 2014They must develop their own state-level versions of ‘repeal and replace.’
- Common Core Cant
Frederick Hess, National Review, March 26, 2014Advocates cite dubious polling to support their claim that the issue is settled.
- Common Core and the Midterms
Frederick Hess, National Review, March 20, 2014It won’t be a huge issue in the fall, but it will have repercussions thereafter.
- Common Core: Teachers’ Unions Think Again
Frederick Hess, National Review, February 21, 2014As implementation nears, they aren’t liking what they see.
- Common Core: Slippery Slope
Frederick Hess and Michael McShane, National Review, December 26, 2013If advocates admitted that it increases Washington’s power, we could have a better, more honest debate.
ARTICLES FOR & AGAINST
- In Defense of the Common Core Standards
Joshua Bleiberg and Darrell West, Brookings Center for Technology and Innovation, March 2014The Common Core standards offer several virtues in terms of innovation, collaboration, and personalized learning.
- Why I Support the Common Core Standards
Bob Riley, National Review Online, March 25, 2014They guarantee educational quality while leaving states, not Washington, in charge.
- How Teachers Unions Use 'Common Core' to Undermine Reform
Eric Hanushek, Wall Street Journal, July 1, 2014Instituting new standards has opened the door for attempts to gut teacher evaluations and 'suspend' accountability.
- Springing to Life: How Greater Educational Equality Could Grow from the Common Core Mathematics Standards
William Schmidt and Nathan Burroughs, American Educator, Spring 2013Empirical research provides some evidence that the Common Core math standards have the potential to increase student achievement.
- Despite All The Conspiracy Theories, Common Core Is Actually Just Boring
Connor Williams, Talking Points Memo, August 5, 2014The Common Core can help us build a baseline of data reliability that will help organize what has traditionally been a stubbornly opaque system.
- Good Reasons Abound to Oppose Common Core
Neal McCluskey, District Administration, June 13, 2014The Common Core, by its nature, must treat every child as essentially the same.
- Doubts Over Common Core Won’t Be Easily Dismissed
George Will, The Washington Post, January 15, 2014What begins with mere national standards must breed ineluctable pressure to standardize educational content.
- Common Core National Standards and Tests: Empty Promises and Increased Federal Overreach Into Education
Lindsey Burke, editor, The Heritage Foundation, October 7, 2013Americans who cherish limited government must be constantly vigilant of pushes to centralize various aspects of our lives. Government intervention is a zero-sum game; every act of centralization comes at the expense of liberty and the civil society institutions upon which this country was founded.
- Everything You Need to Know About the Common Core
Diane Ravitch speech, The Washington Post, January 18I fear that the Common Core plan of standards and testing will establish a test-based meritocracy that will harm our democracy by parceling out opportunity, by ranking and rating every student in relation to their test scores.”
- A Progress Report on the Common Core
Tom Loveless, Brookings, March 18, 2014Evidence shows that standards have little to no impact on student achievement.
RELATED ARTICLES & LINKS