More praise for IQ2 US
“It's a real public service to have debates that bring top-tier participants together and add the sizzle of prize fight competition to a discussion of issues of first-order importance.”
- The Atlantic
Snowden was justified
From the Panel
For: DANIEL ELLSBERG
- Former Whistleblowers: Open Letter to Intelligence Employees After Snowden
Thomas Drake, Daniel Ellsberg, Katharine Gun, Peter Kofod, Ray McGovern, Jesselyn Radack, Coleen Rowley, The Guardian, December 11, 2013Crooked politicians will be held accountable. It's in your hands to be on the right side of history and accelerate the process.
- Snowden Made the Right Call When He Fled the U.S.
Daniel Ellsberg, Washington Post, July 7, 2013Many people compare Edward Snowden to me unfavorably for leaving the country and seeking asylum, rather than facing trial as I did. I don’t agree. The country I stayed in was a different America, a long time ago.
- Edward Snowden: Saving Us from the United Stasi of America
Daniel Ellsberg, The Guardian, June 10, 2013In my estimation, there has not been in American history a more important leak than Edward Snowden’s release of NSA material—and that definitely includes the Pentagon Papers 40 years ago.
- Secrecy and National Security Whistleblowing
Daniel Ellsberg, January 8, 2013, Daniel Ellsberg’s WebsiteAs an urgent matter, the existing secrecy system should be radically contracted and monitored, its current contents generally released (American 'glasnost'), its presumptions debated, challenged and changed.
For: BEN WIZNER
- Edward Snowden’s Legal Adviser Discusses Latest Developments
David Gregory interviews Ben Wizner, Meet the Press, December 29, 2013The ACLU’s Ben Wizner discusses whether Snowden is looking for an amnesty deal and the latest developments surrounding the former NSA contractor.
- Why the Government Wants Your Metadata
Jay Stanley and Ben Wizner, Reuters, June 7, 2013It’s long past time for Congress to update our surveillance and privacy laws to ensure that before the government can go digging through our digital lives, it needs to demonstrate to a judge that it has good reason to believe we’ve done something wrong.
- Edward Snowden Is a Patriot
Anthony Romero, ACLU, December 17, 2013The executive director of the ACLU on Edward Snowden.
Against: ANDREW MCCARTHY
- Not All Truth Telling Is Virtuous
Andrew McCarthy, National Review, June 23, 2013As the crusader for liberty Edward Snowden chooses to flee to totalitarian Russia in anticipation of finding a final soft place to land in some socialist dictatorship, Senator Rand Paul continues to defend him as a ‘truthteller.’
- Debating Government Surveillance: Privacy vs. National Security
University of St. Thomas School of Law’s Hollaran Center for Ethical Leadership in Professions, October 3, 2013Featured speakers in this debate include Andrew McCarthy, Marc Rotenberg, Bruce Schneier, and Steven Bradbury.
- The WHY Question — Why the National-Security Right Is Gradually Losing the NSA Debate
Andrew McCarthy, Ordered Liberty, PJ Media, July 30, 2013Being right on the adequacy of the NSA programs’ structural safeguards, and being right on the law, will count for nothing if Americans are not convinced – quickly – that there is a real, material, comprehensible connection between the massive data collection and the prevention of terrorist attacks.
- Rewriting FISA History
Andrew McCarthy, National Review Online, June 22, 2013Representative Sensenbrenner does not appear to have read the law he ‘wrote.’
Against: R. JAMES WOOLSEY
- CNN Newsroom
Transcript, CNN, December 21, 2013Snowden has caused great damage to the United States and put a number of people at risk of losing their lives, intelligence officers, intelligence agents and others. (For Woolsey segment, scroll midway down page.)
- Ex-CIA Director: Snowden Should Be ‘Hanged’ if Convicted for Treason
Lucas Tomlinson, Fox News, December 17, 2013Former CIA Director James Woolsey had harsh words for anyone thinking about giving Edward Snowden amnesty, and argued the NSA leaker should be “hanged” if he’s ever tried and convicted of treason.
- Opinion Roundup: Edward Snowden and the NSA Leaks
Neal Conan interviews James Woolsey, Talk of the Nation, June 10, 2013‘I think Mr. Snowden should get a fair trial, once we can get him as a result of extradition or something. And if I were on the jury, I would vote for as long a penalty as possible to give under the statute.’
- Why Are Our Nation’s Secrets Entrusted to so Many Government Contractors?
Greta Van Susteren interviews James Woolsey, On the Record, June 11, 2013When you make a decision, as Snowden did, that you're going to take the place of the president and the Congress and the judges that are on the FISA court and you're the one who's going to decide to balance between security and privacy, you are undertaking an action that could get people killed.
ARTICLES FOR & AGAINST
- Edward Snowden, Whistle-Blower
Editorial Board, New York Times, January 1, 2014Snowden was clearly justified in believing that the only way to blow the whistle on this kind of intelligence-gathering was to expose it to the public and let the resulting furor do the work his superiors would not.
- The More I Listen to American Intelligence Officials, the More I Edge Toward Snowden
Thomas Ricks, Foreign Policy, January 10, 2014It is clear that the promises of the president and many Democrats were simply untrue.
- Edward Snowden Is No Traitor
Philip Giraldi, The American Conservative, July 16, 2013Why treason charges against the NSA whistleblower don’t hold up.
- The Three Leakers and What to Do About Them
David Cole, The New York Review of Books, February 6, 2014Snowden has committed serious crimes, but he has also performed a considerable public service.
- Why Snowden Won’t (and Shouldn’t) Get Clemency
Fred Kaplan, Slate, January 3, 2014He went too far to be considered just a whistleblower.
- The Case Against Clemency: Expert Says Snowden’s Leaks Hurt Security
Scott Neuman, NPR, January 9, 2014Stewart Baker, former NSA general counsel, tell Morning Edition that Edward Snowden advertised his theft of government secrets as an act of civil disobedience and should take responsibility.
- The Danger of What Edward Snowden Has Not Revealed
Marc Thiessen, Washington Post, July 1, 2013For U.S. intelligence officials, the far bigger concern is what foreign intelligence services are learning from Snowden that has not made the front pages of the world’s newspapers.
- Edward Snowden Is Completely Wrong
Michael Hirsh and Sara Sorcher, National Journal, June 13, 2013Whether he's a hero or traitor, Americans are already so acclimated to the loss of privacy that his revelations won't unnerve them much.
RELATED ARTICLES & LINKS